Tonight,
esrblog and I went with
pmat and
shakati to see the new Star Trek movie.
I really enjoyed it. The best part was how well the young actors playing...the counterparts of the beloved Star Trek characters captured the personalities of those characters.
I won't go into the kind of detail that would require an lj-cut to avoid spoilers, but I will make a few comments about various aspects of the movie.
* The casting; splendid. Even with regard to the minor characters; Captain Pike was particularly good.
* The visuals; excellent. The Enterprise looked much the same as always, from the outside, but the inside was much higher-tech than the Enterprise of the old 1960s series. The crew uniforms were mixed. The off-duty uniforms were spiffier than what the original Enterprise bridge crew wore, but the bridge crew here wore uniforms of an even cheesier fabric than the jersey used in the original series.
* The plot concept; not bad. It involves temporal paradox, as a number of reviewers mentioned. It also gave Leonard Nimoy a splendid opportunity for a cameo performance that he obviously relished.
* The plot holes; characteristic of Trek as usual.
* The physics; ah, don't ask.
* The prospect for more sequels; fairly good actually, but if they keep this cast, I'll watch them. Every one.
I really enjoyed it. The best part was how well the young actors playing...the counterparts of the beloved Star Trek characters captured the personalities of those characters.
I won't go into the kind of detail that would require an lj-cut to avoid spoilers, but I will make a few comments about various aspects of the movie.
* The casting; splendid. Even with regard to the minor characters; Captain Pike was particularly good.
* The visuals; excellent. The Enterprise looked much the same as always, from the outside, but the inside was much higher-tech than the Enterprise of the old 1960s series. The crew uniforms were mixed. The off-duty uniforms were spiffier than what the original Enterprise bridge crew wore, but the bridge crew here wore uniforms of an even cheesier fabric than the jersey used in the original series.
* The plot concept; not bad. It involves temporal paradox, as a number of reviewers mentioned. It also gave Leonard Nimoy a splendid opportunity for a cameo performance that he obviously relished.
* The plot holes; characteristic of Trek as usual.
* The physics; ah, don't ask.
* The prospect for more sequels; fairly good actually, but if they keep this cast, I'll watch them. Every one.
(no subject)
edited to change userpics
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
(no subject)
I liked how during the entire movie, he never actually _solves_ a single problem by himself. Somebody _else_ solved it. (Pike ponders having him thrown in the brig as a stowaway: Uhura saves his bacon. Fight on the drill platform: Sulu saves his bacon. Jumping to rescue with the parachute: Checov saves his bacon. Chased by a giant critter on an ice planet: Kirk is positively _screwed_ until Spock prime shows up out of nowhere to save his bacon, and then Scotty gets them back into the action. Confrontation with the romulans: spock takes out the enemy ship, the enterprise beams them all to safety. Kirk does actually manage to rescue pike, which he couldn't have done without Pike.
He's a great tank, and he can even lead a bit, but he's not the guy who really _does_ most of the thing that need doing.
(no subject)
Fade's right. The characters do work together amazingly well, even before they've gotten to know each other. In a way that's as improbable as some of the movie's physics, but unlike the bad physics it makes the story *more* fun and more satisfying.